Police departments often claim encryption is necessary for modern policing. Comparing similar cities—one encrypted, one open—shows that claim doesn't hold up.
Same challenges, different choices
Tampa and Miami face similar crime rates, hurricane threats, and population sizes. Tampa maintains open communications; Miami went dark. That difference is a policy decision, not a technical requirement.
Documented outcomes
After the 2022 Highland Park shooting, Chicago's major newsrooms wrote that the media and the public turned to police scanners "to take cover, to stay safe, to locate the missing." In the same December 2022 letter, they wrote that Chicago's block on live scanner transmissions kept the public from learning of a courthouse shooting as it happened.
Evidence for advocacy
When your city considers encryption, these comparisons give you something concrete to cite. Point to Tampa. Quote the Chicago newsrooms on Highland Park. Ask officials to explain why their city needs what Tampa chose not to do.