How to Request Police Radio Recordings Through FOIA
Police radio recordings are public records in most jurisdictions. When departments encrypt their communications, FOIA (Freedom of Information Act) requests become your only tool for accessing this information. Here's how to successfully request police audio.
Understanding FOIA and Police Records
The federal Freedom of Information Act applies to federal agencies. For local police departments, you'll use your state's public records law—often called a "sunshine law" or state FOIA equivalent.
State Laws by Name
- California: California Public Records Act (CPRA)
- Texas: Texas Public Information Act
- Florida: Government-in-the-Sunshine Law
- New York: Freedom of Information Law (FOIL)
- Illinois: Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)
Every state has equivalent legislation—search for "[Your State] public records law" for specifics.
What's Typically Available
- Dispatch recordings - Calls between dispatch and officers
- 911 recordings - Emergency calls (may require separate request)
- Radio traffic logs - Written logs of transmissions if audio unavailable
- CAD (Computer Aided Dispatch) data - Digital records of calls and responses
What's Typically Exempt
- Ongoing investigation communications
- Undercover officer identities
- Tactical operation details
- Victim personal information (may be redacted)
- Juvenile case information
Before You Request
1. Identify the Right Agency
Police radio systems can be operated by different entities:
- City police - Request goes to municipal police department
- County sheriff - Request goes to sheriff's office
- Regional dispatch center - May be separate agency handling multiple departments
- State police - State-level public records process
If you're unsure who handles dispatch, call the police department's non-emergency line and ask.
2. Check Retention Periods
Agencies purge old recordings on schedule. Before requesting, find out:
- How long are routine recordings kept? (Often 90 days to 1 year)
- Are recordings preserved for major incidents?
- Can you request a "litigation hold" to preserve specific recordings?
Time Is Critical
If you need recordings from a specific incident, request immediately. Many agencies purge routine recordings after 30-90 days. Once deleted, the audio is gone permanently.
3. Narrow Your Request
Overly broad requests get delayed or denied. Be specific about:
- Date and time range - As narrow as possible
- Location - Specific address or intersection
- Incident type - "All radio traffic related to the traffic stop at..."
- Format preference - Digital download, CD, or USB drive
Writing an Effective Request
Key Elements of a Good Request
- Cite the specific law
Reference your state's public records statute by name and section number. This shows you know your rights.
- Describe records precisely
Date, time, location, incident type. Vague requests invite delays.
- Request format you want
Digital format (MP3, WAV) is usually cheapest. CDs or USB drives may cost extra.
- Ask about fee estimates
Request a fee estimate before they begin work. Ask about fee waivers for public interest.
- Set a deadline
Most states have response deadlines (5-10 business days). Note the statutory deadline in your request.
- Request Vaughn index if denied
Ask them to identify which specific exemption applies to which specific records if they deny any part.
What to Avoid
- Don't explain why you want it - You don't have to justify your request. Reasons can be used to limit release.
- Don't request "all records related to..." - Too vague, invites delays and high fees.
- Don't be confrontational - Professional requests get better results.
- Don't accept "we don't have that" without verification - Ask for confirmation in writing.
Sample Request Letters
Sample: Specific Incident Recording
[Your Name]
[Your Address]
[City, State ZIP]
[Email Address]
[Date]
Records Custodian
[Police Department Name]
[Address]
[City, State ZIP]
RE: Public Records Request - Police Radio Recordings
Dear Records Custodian:
Pursuant to the [State Name] Public Records Act ([cite statute, e.g., "California Government Code Section 6250 et seq."]), I request copies of the following records:
All police radio/dispatch recordings related to the incident at [specific address] on [date] between [start time] and [end time].
This request includes all communications between dispatch and responding officers, as well as any officer-to-officer radio traffic related to this incident.
I request these records in digital format (MP3 or WAV preferred) via email or secure download link.
Please provide a fee estimate before beginning work on this request. If fees exceed $25, please contact me for approval. I request a waiver of fees as this information serves the public interest by promoting transparency in police operations.
Under [state statute], you must respond to this request within [X] business days. If you deny any part of this request, please provide a written explanation citing the specific statutory exemption and a Vaughn index of withheld materials.
Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
Sample: General Policy/Retention Request
RE: Public Records Request - Radio Recording Policies
Dear Records Custodian:
Pursuant to the [State] Public Records Act, I request copies of:
- The department's current policy regarding retention of police radio recordings
- Any contracts with vendors who store or manage police radio communications
- Documentation of the department's radio encryption policy, if any
- Records showing when the department began encrypting police radio communications, if applicable
Please provide records in digital format. I request a fee waiver as these records serve the public interest.
Thank you for your compliance with public records law.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
Common Exemptions and How to Counter
Exemption: "Ongoing Investigation"
What they claim: Records could compromise an active investigation.
How to counter:
- Ask when the investigation will conclude
- Request a timeline for release after investigation closes
- Ask for portions unrelated to investigation—dispatch timeline, response times
- Point out that most routine calls aren't "investigations"
Exemption: "Officer Safety"
What they claim: Release would endanger officers.
How to counter:
- Request redaction of specific tactical information rather than complete denial
- Ask what specific information poses a safety risk
- Point out that scanners broadcast this information publicly in real-time (if not encrypted)
- Request delayed release after incident is resolved
Exemption: "Personal Privacy"
What they claim: Recording contains private information about individuals.
How to counter:
- Request redaction of personal info (names, addresses, phone numbers) rather than denial
- Note that officer actions in public are not private
- Public interest in oversight often outweighs privacy
- Ask for a Vaughn index identifying what's being withheld and why
Exemption: "We Don't Have It"
What they claim: No responsive records exist.
How to counter:
- Ask for confirmation in writing that a reasonable search was conducted
- Ask who maintains recordings if not this agency
- Request retention policy to understand if records should exist
- Ask about third-party vendors who might hold recordings
Appealing Denials
Most states have a multi-level appeal process. Don't give up after the first denial.
Typical Appeal Levels
- Internal Appeal
Request review by agency head or legal counsel. Often required before external appeal.
- State Oversight Body
Many states have a public records ombudsman or attorney general office that reviews denials.
- Court Challenge
File a lawsuit in state court. Many states allow recovery of attorney fees if you prevail.
Appeal Letter Elements
- Reference original request and denial
- Quote the specific exemption they cited
- Explain why the exemption doesn't apply
- Cite case law supporting your position if available
- Request expedited review
Free Legal Resources
- Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press - Free legal help for journalists
- Student Press Law Center - Assists student journalists
- State press associations - Often have legal hotlines
- ACLU state chapters - May assist with significant transparency cases
The Encryption Connection
Police radio encryption fundamentally changes the relationship between public access and FOIA requests.
Before Encryption
- Real-time public access via scanners
- Immediate awareness of police activity
- FOIA used mainly for permanent records or specific investigations
- Public can independently verify police accounts
After Encryption
- Zero real-time public access
- FOIA becomes the only way to access police communications
- Significant delays (weeks to months) before information available
- Agencies can cite exemptions to deny access entirely
- Cost barriers limit who can request records
FOIA Is Not a Replacement for Scanner Access
When departments claim you can "just FOIA the recordings," they're ignoring critical differences:
- Timing: Scanner = real-time; FOIA = weeks/months later
- Cost: Scanner = free; FOIA = fees and time investment
- Access: Scanner = automatic; FOIA = requires knowledge and effort
- Denial: Scanner = can't be denied; FOIA = routinely denied on exemptions
Using FOIA to Fight Encryption
FOIA requests can be powerful tools in the fight against encryption:
- Request the decision-making process - Who decided to encrypt? What alternatives were considered?
- Request cost data - How much did encryption cost taxpayers?
- Request justification documents - What evidence supported the claim that encryption was necessary?
- Request complaint records - Has the public complained about losing access?
- Request policy documents - What does the encryption policy actually say?
Frequently Asked Questions
Are police radio recordings public records?
In most states, police radio recordings are considered public records subject to disclosure. However, they may be exempt during ongoing investigations, contain redactable personal information, or be withheld for officer safety reasons in certain cases.
How long do police departments keep radio recordings?
Retention periods vary widely—from 30 days to several years depending on the agency and state requirements. Most departments keep routine recordings for 90 days to one year. Recordings related to significant incidents or lawsuits are kept longer. Request promptly to avoid missing the retention window.
Can police deny my request for radio recordings?
Agencies can deny requests citing exemptions like ongoing investigations, officer safety, or privacy concerns. However, many denials can be appealed. Partial redaction (bleeping sensitive info) is often possible instead of complete denial.
How much does it cost to get police radio recordings?
Costs vary by agency. Many charge per-hour search fees ($25-50/hour) plus media costs ($5-25 per CD/USB). Some agencies waive fees for journalists or small requests. Ask about fee waivers for public interest requests.
How does encryption affect FOIA requests for police audio?
Encryption doesn't change your legal right to request recordings—departments still must record and retain radio traffic. However, encryption eliminates real-time public access. FOIA requests become your only option for police radio information when communications are encrypted.
Take Action for Transparency
Your voice matters. Here are concrete ways to advocate for open police communications in your community.
Contact Your Representatives
Use our templates to email your local officials about police radio encryption policies.
Get StartedRead Case Studies
See how encryption has affected real communities - from Highland Park to Chicago.
View CasesSpread Awareness
Share evidence about police radio encryption with your network and community.
Public Testimony
Learn how to speak effectively at city council and public safety meetings.
Prepare to Speak