Advertisement
Legislative Victory

Colorado HB21-1250: The 2021 Law Requiring Media Access Policies for Encrypted Police Radio

After three consecutive years of failed attempts, Colorado lawmakers in 2021 passed a law requiring police departments and sheriff's offices that encrypt all of their radio to create media access policies. While implementation challenges persist, HB21-1250 provides a legislative blueprint for other states seeking to mandate transparency.

What Coloradans can still monitor while HB21-1250 gets enforced

Legislation is the real fix—scanner gear won't unlock DPD's AES. But while Colorado works through implementation, many Front Range and Western Slope agencies remain open, and NOAA weather plus federal/aviation/amateur bands stay unencrypted. For wildfire and avalanche country, a weather radio is not optional.

Key Facts at a Glance

3 Years of failed bills before success
2021 HB21-1250 signed into law
0 Media orgs in Aurora's access agreement (Aug 2022)
Advertisement

The Legislative Journey: Three Years of Persistence

Colorado's path to HB21-1250 wasn't easy. It took three consecutive legislative sessions before transparency advocates finally succeeded.

2018: HB18-1061

First attempt to require unencrypted dispatch communications is postponed indefinitely in committee. It would have required dispatch radio to be broadcast without encryption, with exceptions for tactical or investigative communications.

2019: HB19-1235

Second attempt is postponed indefinitely in committee. It would have required government entities to broadcast dispatch radio without encryption.

2020: HB20-1282

Third attempt, and the first of the three to propose a media-access policy instead of a ban: a government entity that encrypts all of its radio would have had to adopt an encryption policy including access by members of the media. Postponed indefinitely in committee on March 4, 2020.

2021: HB21-1250 Passes

Republican Rep. Kevin Van Winkle suggests a streamlined media-access amendment during House floor debate on broader police accountability legislation. The governor signs the bill on July 6, 2021.

2022-Present

Implementation challenges: Denver and Aurora fail to reach workable agreements with news organizations despite the law's requirements.

The Winning Strategy: Attach to Reform

The breakthrough came when advocates changed their approach. Instead of pursuing standalone encryption bills that died in committee, they attached transparency requirements to broader police reform legislation.

The Vehicle: HB21-1250

A broader police accountability bill that built on the major law enforcement reform measure (SB 20-217) passed in 2020. It addressed body cameras, dashboard footage releases, and whistleblower protections.

The Champion: Rep. Kevin Van Winkle

A Republican from Highlands Ranch, he suggested the encryption amendment during House floor debate, a streamlined version of his earlier standalone bill. The Colorado Broadcasters Association later said it worked with bipartisan legislators to add the language.

The Coalition: Colorado Broadcasters

The Colorado Broadcasters Association, led by CEO Justin Sasso (a Colorado FOIC board member), called the amendment "the first step toward good faith negotiations between law enforcement and broadcasters …"

"…the first step toward good faith negotiations between law enforcement and broadcasters…"

— Justin Sasso, Colorado Broadcasters Association, as reported by CFOIC (May 19, 2021)

What the Law Requires

HB21-1250 created specific obligations for a municipal police department or county sheriff's office that encrypts all of its radio communications:

1

Create Access Policies

Agencies must create a "communications access policy" permitting news media to access primary dispatch channels.

2

Enable Scanner Access

Access must be available "through commercially available radio receivers, scanners, or other feasible technology."

3

Reasonable Restrictions Only

Policies may include verification of media credentials, "reasonable restrictions" on the use of the receivers or scanners, and costs for their sale, lease or loan.

4

Seek Media Input

The policy must be created in collaboration with Colorado-based media outlets.

The Key Legal Language

C.R.S. 24-6-502, added by Section 19 of HB21-1250: "A law enforcement agency that encrypts all of its radio communications shall create a communications access policy, through collaboration with Colorado-based media outlets, that includes an agreement governing access for the media to primary dispatch channels or talk groups …" This creates an affirmative obligation—agencies cannot simply encrypt and walk away.

Implementation Challenges: The Law vs. Reality

The Colorado Broadcasters Association said in 2022 it had been "met with stonewalling, finger pointing and runaround tactics for over a year." More than a year after passage, the Colorado Freedom of Information Coalition reported that reporters still could not tune into Denver and Aurora police radio transmissions.

Denver Police Department

Encrypted: 2019

  • Developed a written policy but reached no agreements with Denver metro news organizations
  • Primary obstacle: an "auditor's clause" requiring the city auditor access to news organization records
  • Matt Lunn, the Denver Police Department's manager of strategic initiatives: "we don't have the ability … to remove that from any of our contracts"
  • Result: Journalists still blocked from police radio access

Aurora Police Department

Encrypted: 2016

  • Published policy in January 2021 with only one media inquiry received
  • No news organizations have signed the access agreement
  • Policy includes problematic indemnification provisions
  • Result: Aurora said in 2022 that "No media organization has entered into the agreement"

"We've been met with stonewalling, finger pointing and runaround tactics for over a year."

— Justin Sasso, Colorado Broadcasters Association President

The Impact on Journalism

The encryption problem in Colorado isn't theoretical. Journalists describe concrete harms to their ability to cover breaking news.

Delayed Coverage

"Sometimes we were an hour late to the scene, or more," reported Denver Post reporter Elise Schmelzer. Without scanner access, journalists depend entirely on official police notifications.

One-Sided Narratives

When police control the flow of information, the public only gets the official version of events. Independent verification becomes impossible in the critical first hours.

Safety Concerns

Residents in active emergency situations can't monitor scanner traffic to understand what's happening in their neighborhoods.

Advertisement

Why Colorado Matters: A Legislative Blueprint

Despite implementation challenges, Colorado's approach offers valuable lessons for other states:

1

Attach to Larger Bills

Standalone encryption bills died three years in a row. Success came when the provision was attached to broader police accountability legislation.

2

Build Bipartisan Support

Republican Rep. Kevin Van Winkle offered the amendment to a police-accountability bill whose prime sponsors were Reps. Herod and Gonzales-Gutierrez and Sens. Fields and Gardner, and the Colorado Broadcasters Association said it worked with bipartisan legislators.

3

Coalition with Broadcasters

The Colorado Broadcasters Association says it "worked tirelessly with bipartisan legislators" to add the encryption language.

4

Plan for Enforcement

Colorado's law lacks strong enforcement mechanisms. Future legislation should include penalties for non-compliance and clearer deadlines.

5

Define "Reasonable" Narrowly

Vague language about "reasonable restrictions" has allowed agencies to impose onerous requirements. Specific, narrow definitions prevent loopholes.

6

Persist Through Failure

Three years of failed bills preceded success. Legislative change requires persistence—don't give up after the first rejection.

The Scope of Encryption in Colorado

More than 30 law enforcement agencies in Colorado had encrypted their dispatch communications by May 2021, according to the Colorado Freedom of Information Coalition; in August 2022 it put the figure at "at least 30." They include:

Major encrypted departments

  • Denver Police — encrypted since 2019
  • Aurora Police — encrypted since 2016
  • Colorado Springs Police — encrypted; CFOIC reported in August 2022 that it had reached agreements with local newsrooms to provide radio access

Lessons for Other States

If your state is considering legislation to address police radio encryption, Colorado's experience offers both a model and cautionary tale:

Use Colorado's Language as a Starting Point

The requirement to create "communications access policies" for media is a good foundation. Build on it with stronger enforcement mechanisms.

Add Enforcement Teeth

Colorado's law lacks penalties for non-compliance. Include specific consequences—fines, oversight board review, or automatic access rights if agencies fail to comply.

Set Clear Deadlines

Require agencies to have working access programs within 90 days of encryption adoption, with specific milestones and public reporting.

Prohibit Poison Pills

Explicitly prohibit access agreements that require media to accept indemnification clauses or auditor access to their records.

Create a Model Agreement

Include model access agreement language in the legislation itself, reducing agencies' ability to impose unreasonable terms.

Establish Oversight

Create an oversight body—perhaps the state press association or an independent commission—to review compliance and hear complaints.

How to Fight Encryption FOIA Request Templates Public Testimony Guide

Sources

Take Action for Transparency

Your voice matters. Here are concrete ways to advocate for open police communications in your community.

Contact Your Representatives

Use our templates to email your local officials about police radio encryption policies.

Get started

Read Case Studies

See how encryption has affected real communities - from Chicago to Palo Alto.

View cases

Spread Awareness

Share evidence about police radio encryption with your network and community.

See the Evidence

Review the facts, myths, and research on police radio encryption.

View evidence

Public Testimony

Learn how to speak effectively at city council and public safety meetings.

Prepare to speak

Download Resources

Get FOIA templates, talking points, and materials for advocacy.

Access toolkit

What you can do

Encryption is a policy choice, not a technical requirement. Here are the next steps that have worked in Colorado and elsewhere.

Advertisement

Agency records in Colorado

Encryption status for individual agencies, each checked against a primary source where one was available.

All Colorado agencies →