FOIA Templates
Your Public Records Arsenal
These public records requests test the evidence for encryption. When a newspaper asked Palo Alto for three years of reports of crimes aided by a police scanner, the city had none on record.
The FOIA Strategy
1. Request the evidence
Ask for documented cases of scanner access harming officers. If the answer is "no responsive records," quote it exactly.
2. Follow the money
Request cost documents, vendor proposals, and budget allocations. Millions spent with no proven benefit is a powerful argument.
3. Expose the process
Request internal communications about encryption. Discover who pushed for it, what alternatives were considered, and whether the public was consulted.
Template #1: Scanner Harm Documentation
The most important request—this often wins the entire argument
Request for Documented Scanner-Related Incidents
Use this request to find out whether the department has any record of scanner access harming officers or operations.
Subject: Public Records Request - Police Radio Scanner Incidents
To [Records Custodian/FOIA Officer],
Under [State] public records law / Freedom of Information Act, I request copies of the following records:
- All documented incidents where public access to police radio communications (via scanner, Broadcastify, or similar means) resulted in:
- Injury to any police officer
- Harm to any police operation
- Compromise of any investigation
- Flight or escape of a suspect
- Any other documented negative outcome attributed to scanner access
- All incident reports, memos, or communications documenting any of the above.
- Any studies, analyses, or assessments conducted by the department regarding risks associated with public scanner access.
Time period: [Last 5 years] to present
If no responsive records exist for any category, please confirm in writing that "no responsive records were located."
Please provide records in electronic format (PDF preferred) to: [your email]
If you anticipate fees exceeding $25, please contact me before proceeding.
Thank you for your assistance.
[Your Name]
[Address]
[Email]
[Phone]
How to use this response
- If the response says "no responsive records," quote it accurately in testimony: "Asked for [X years] of records of scanner access causing harm, the department replied that it had no responsive records." Also ask whether the department keeps that statistic at all; Palo Alto, for one, said it does not.
- If they do find something, review it carefully. Most so-called "incidents" are hypothetical concerns, not actual documented harm—challenge weak evidence.
- If they delay, follow up in writing. Delays often suggest the agency is searching for something that doesn't exist.
Template #2: Encryption Cost Documentation
Follow the money—encryption is expensive with no proven ROI
Request for Encryption System Costs
Use this request to document the full cost of encryption and challenge the budget justification.
Subject: Public Records Request - Radio Encryption Costs
To [Records Custodian/FOIA Officer],
Under [State] public records law, I request copies of the following records:
- All budget proposals, line items, and appropriations related to police radio encryption, radio system upgrades, or P25 system implementation, including:
- Initial implementation costs
- Hardware and equipment purchases
- Software licensing fees
- Consultant or vendor fees
- Training costs
- Ongoing maintenance and support costs (annual)
- All vendor proposals, quotes, or contracts for encrypted radio systems.
- Any cost-benefit analyses conducted regarding radio encryption.
- Any grant applications or awards used to fund encryption systems.
Time period: [Last 3 years] to present
Please provide records in electronic format to: [your email]
Thank you for your assistance.
[Your Name]
[Address]
[Email]
[Phone]
How to use this response
- Add up all line items to calculate the true total cost. Encryption systems commonly run $500K to $5M or more.
- With no documented harm shown to have been prevented, the question to put to officials is: "What did the public get for [X million dollars]?"
- Propose what that money could fund instead: additional officers, community programs, or other public safety improvements.
Template #3: Decision-Making Communications
Expose who pushed for encryption and what alternatives were considered
Request for Encryption Decision Communications
Use this request to understand the decision-making process and identify what alternatives were actually considered.
Subject: Public Records Request - Radio Encryption Decision Process
To [Records Custodian/FOIA Officer],
Under [State] public records law, I request copies of the following records:
- All communications (emails, memos, letters, meeting notes) between department personnel regarding police radio encryption, including:
- Internal discussions about encryption plans
- Communications with city/county officials
- Communications with vendors
- Communications with other law enforcement agencies
- All meeting agendas, minutes, and presentations regarding radio encryption decisions.
- Any public notice or community engagement documents related to encryption decisions.
- Any analysis of alternatives to full encryption (such as hybrid systems, delayed feeds, or media access programs).
- Any policies or procedures regarding radio communication encryption.
Time period: [Last 2 years] to present
Search terms: "encryption," "encrypted," "P25," "radio security," "scanner," "Broadcastify"
Please provide records in electronic format to: [your email]
Thank you for your assistance.
[Your Name]
[Address]
[Email]
[Phone]
What to look for
- Was the community ever notified or consulted? Many encryption decisions happen without any public input.
- Look for evidence of vendor influence—did equipment vendors push encryption as a way to sell new systems?
- Were hybrid systems considered, and if so, why were they rejected?
- Did anyone inside the department raise concerns about the decision?
Template #4: Media Access Policies
Document current press access and any changes planned
Request for Media Access Policies
Use this request to understand how encryption affects press access and what accommodations, if any, exist.
Subject: Public Records Request - Media Access to Police Communications
To [Records Custodian/FOIA Officer],
Under [State] public records law, I request copies of the following records:
- All policies and procedures regarding media access to police radio communications.
- Any media credentialing programs that provide journalists access to encrypted communications.
- Any agreements or MOUs with news organizations regarding scanner or radio access.
- Any delayed or time-shifted public access systems (such as delayed feeds on Broadcastify or similar platforms).
- All communications with news organizations regarding radio encryption or access changes.
- Any complaints or concerns received from journalists or media organizations about encryption.
Time period: [Last 2 years] to present
Please provide records in electronic format to: [your email]
Thank you for your assistance.
[Your Name]
[Address]
[Email]
[Phone]
How to use this response
- If no credentialing program exists, push for one as a minimum compromise.
- If delayed feeds run 30 minutes or longer, advocate for shorter delay windows that still allow timely news coverage.
- Any documented complaints from media organizations are useful evidence to cite in council testimony.
Filing Tips
How to maximize your chances of getting useful records
Know your law
Research your state's public records law. Requirements vary by state. Some have stricter timelines, lower fees, or broader access than federal FOIA.
Be specific
Vague requests get vague responses. List specific document types, time periods, and search terms. The more precise your request, the better your results.
Request electronic format
Always ask for records in electronic format (PDF, email files). It's usually cheaper and faster than paper copies.
Set fee limits
Ask to be contacted if fees exceed a certain amount (e.g., $25 or $50). This prevents surprise bills and lets you narrow the request if needed.
Follow up
If you don't receive a response within the statutory deadline, send a follow-up. Document all communications in case you need to appeal.
Request "no records" confirmation
Always ask them to confirm in writing if no records exist. That written confirmation is evidence you can use in testimony.
File multiple requests
Don't put everything in one request. Separate requests for different topics are often processed faster.
Appeal denials
If your request is denied or heavily redacted, you usually have the right to appeal. Many denials are overturned on appeal.
FOIA Results That Changed Outcomes
Palo Alto, California
The Palo Alto Daily Post requested any report from January 2018 to January 2021 of a crime in which a suspect was aided by a police scanner or police radio. The city replied that it had "no responsive records" and that its police department does not keep that statistic (Palo Alto Daily Post, May 28, 2021). In August 2022 the acting police chief announced the main dispatch channel would be unencrypted (Palo Alto Online, Aug. 4, 2022).
Broadcastify Founder's Statement
Broadcastify founder Lindsay Blanton told Built In in June 2020: "We've never had a law enforcement agency present us with evidence that we've put officers in danger by what we do." (Built In, June 23, 2020)
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about filing FOIA requests on police encryption
What is the most effective FOIA request to fight police encryption?
The 'scanner harm documentation' request is most powerful. Ask for all documented incidents where scanner access caused officer harm, operational compromise, or suspect escape. If the answer is 'no responsive records', quote it exactly: the agency has no record of such harm to cite.
How long does a FOIA response take?
Most jurisdictions must respond within 5-10 business days. Mark your calendar and follow up if you don't receive acknowledgment. Some agencies may request extensions for large requests.
What if my FOIA request is denied?
File an appeal citing public interest. Many denials are overturned on appeal. If you receive 'no responsive records,' that's strong evidence—quote it exactly: the agency has no record of scanner-related harm to cite.
What should I request about encryption costs?
Request budget proposals, vendor quotes, cost estimates, maintenance contracts, and total expenditures for encryption systems. This data shows millions spent with no proven benefit—a powerful argument at budget hearings.
Take Action for Transparency
Your voice matters. Here are concrete ways to advocate for open police communications in your community.
Contact Your Representatives
Use our templates to email your local officials about police radio encryption policies.
Get startedRead Case Studies
See how encryption has affected real communities - from Chicago to Palo Alto.
View casesSpread Awareness
Share evidence about police radio encryption with your network and community.
Public Testimony
Learn how to speak effectively at city council and public safety meetings.
Prepare to speak