Advertisement
ACTIVIST PLAYBOOK

Public Testimony Guide

Own the Public Comment Period

Most officials have never heard organized opposition to encryption. When you show up prepared with evidence and personal stories, you make an impression that's hard to ignore.

1

Most comment periods run 2–3 minutes. Practice with a timer.

2

Lead with your strongest point. Don't build to it—officials often stop listening early.

3

Stay professional. Hostile tone backfires; measured criticism lands.

4

Cite evidence. A records response quoted exactly is more persuasive than any opinion.

5

Ask questions that force officials to respond to specific challenges.

Core 2-Minute Script

A complete testimony you can customize

General opposition testimony

~2 minutes

INTRODUCTION (15 sec)

"My name is [NAME] and I'm a [resident/parent/journalist/business owner] in [CITY]. I'm here to urge you to reject police radio encryption."

THE PROBLEM WITH ENCRYPTION (30 sec)

"After the 2022 Highland Park parade shooting, Chicago's major news organizations wrote that the media and the public turned to police scanners 'to take cover, to stay safe, to locate the missing.' Encryption would eliminate that real-time information with nothing to replace it."

THE EVIDENCE (30 sec)

"When a newspaper asked Palo Alto for three years of reports of crimes aided by a police scanner, the city answered that it had no responsive records. None. The problem encryption supposedly solves does not exist."

THE ALTERNATIVE (20 sec)

"Better solutions exist. Hybrid systems encrypt tactical operations while keeping routine dispatch open. This approach serves police needs without eliminating community access."

THE ASK (20 sec)

"I ask the council: Before spending [COST] on encryption, demand documented evidence of actual harm. Vote for transparency over secrecy. Vote for public safety over police convenience. Thank you."

Angle-Specific Scripts

Coordinate different speakers covering different perspectives

Parent/family safety

"My name is [NAME]. I have children at [SCHOOL]. When there's a lockdown, I don't wait for the school's text message that comes 20 minutes late. I monitor the police scanner to know exactly what's happening and whether my kids are safe.

After the Highland Park shooting, Chicago's newsrooms wrote that the public turned to police scanners 'to locate the missing.' Encryption takes that away.

Don't tell me encryption makes my family safer. It does the opposite."

Journalist/press freedom

"I'm [NAME] with [OUTLET]. Police scanners are how journalists get to breaking news. We monitor them to serve our community with timely, accurate reporting.

Encryption means we arrive 30 minutes late, after police have controlled the scene and the narrative. That's not journalism—that's stenography.

The First Amendment protects press freedom. Encryption undermines it. We urge you to preserve our ability to report on what police actually do, not just what they choose to tell us."

Fire/EMS interoperability

"I'm [NAME], a [firefighter/EMT/emergency manager]. When police encrypt their radios, we lose crucial situational awareness.

At multi-agency incidents, we need to know what police are seeing and doing. Encryption creates dangerous coordination gaps. In Washington DC, fire crews at a subway incident couldn't coordinate with encrypted police units—the system was reversed after that failure.

Public safety requires interoperability. Encryption breaks it."

Accountability and oversight

"At Uvalde, police radio audio contradicted official accounts and exposed failures. In 2020, scanner audio documented racist remarks by officers during protests.

Encryption didn't surge after some documented security failure—it surged after 2020, after scanners exposed police misconduct. This is about avoiding accountability, not protecting officers.

Public servants doing public work should be publicly observable. Vote for transparency."

Fiscal/cost argument

"This encryption proposal costs [AMOUNT]. For that money, we could hire [X] officers, fund [X] community programs, or improve [X] infrastructure.

What documented benefit will we receive for this investment? Zero. No one has named a documented case of scanner access harming an officer here.

This is [AMOUNT] spent on a solution to a problem that doesn't exist. That's not responsible budgeting."

Disability and accessibility

"For people who are deaf or hard of hearing, text-based scanner apps provide emergency awareness that's otherwise inaccessible.

Encryption eliminates this accessibility accommodation with no replacement. Emergency alert systems are slow and incomplete compared to real-time scanner access.

I urge you to consider the accessibility implications before implementing encryption."

Preparation Checklist

What to do before, during, and after your testimony

Before the meeting

  • Practice your testimony with a timer—stay under time limit
  • Print copies of your statement to leave with clerk
  • Prepare a written version for the official record
  • Sign up early for public comment (slots are limited)
  • Coordinate with coalition on speaking order and angles
  • Dress professionally—first impressions matter
  • Arrive early to get a seat and observe the process

During your testimony

  • Speak slowly and clearly into the microphone
  • Make eye contact with council members
  • Don't read word-for-word—know your points
  • If you run short, that's okay—don't ramble
  • If interrupted, pause and continue professionally
  • Thank the council for their time at the end
  • Stay calm even if officials are dismissive

After the meeting

  • Submit written testimony for the official record
  • Debrief with coalition on what worked
  • Follow up with sympathetic council members
  • If media is present, be available for interviews
  • Document the meeting and any commitments made
  • Plan for next meeting if decision was delayed

Handling Common Pushback

What officials say and how to respond

"Officer safety requires encryption"

If scanner access endangered officers, departments should be able to name the cases. We know of no named, documented one; a 2022 CISA paper cites only anonymized examples. Asked by a newspaper for three years of reports of scanner-aided crime, Palo Alto had none on record. The burden of proof rests with those making the claim.

"Victim privacy requires encryption"

Officers rarely broadcast victim names or addresses on dispatch. Fire departments handle sensitive medical information without encryption every day. Privacy can be protected through training and policy—not blanket secrecy.

"Other cities have encrypted"

Other cities doing something wrong doesn't make it right. Many jurisdictions use hybrid systems that protect tactical operations while keeping dispatch open. We should follow best practices, not follow the crowd.

"The police chief says it's necessary"

The police chief works for the city, not the other way around. Elected officials have the authority and responsibility to make policy. Chiefs often prefer secrecy—that doesn't mean the community is obligated to accept it.

"This is a technical/operational decision"

Transparency is a democratic value, not a technical question. The community has a right to weigh in on policies that affect public access to information about police activities.

"Criminals use scanners to evade police"

Where is the evidence? Asked by a newspaper for three years of reports of crimes aided by a police scanner, Palo Alto had none on record. Named cases are few: Virginia Beach police described a 2011 case in which a burglary suspect slipped away after listening to officers plan his arrest on a scanner app (Virginian-Pilot via GovTech, May 8, 2018). Ask your department for its own records.

Coordinating Multiple Speakers

When you have a coalition, organize for maximum impact

Divide the angles

Assign different speakers to different topics: public safety, journalism, fire/EMS, cost, accountability. Avoid repetition—each speaker should cover new ground.

Strategic order

Lead with your most credible speaker (journalist, fire chief, business leader). Save personal stories for middle. Close with a strong call to action.

Visual impact

Have all supporters wear the same color or hold identical signs. Visual unity shows organized opposition that officials can't dismiss.

Fill the room

Even if not everyone speaks, filling seats demonstrates community concern. Numbers matter—officials notice when the room is packed.

Take Action for Transparency

Your voice matters. Here are concrete ways to advocate for open police communications in your community.

Contact Your Representatives

Use our templates to email your local officials about police radio encryption policies.

Get started

Read Case Studies

See how encryption has affected real communities - from Chicago to Palo Alto.

View cases

Spread Awareness

Share evidence about police radio encryption with your network and community.

See the Evidence

Review the facts, myths, and research on police radio encryption.

View evidence

Public Testimony

Learn how to speak effectively at city council and public safety meetings.

Prepare to speak

Download Resources

Get FOIA templates, talking points, and materials for advocacy.

Access toolkit