Encrypted vs Open Cities: A Side-by-Side Reality Check
Police departments claim encryption is necessary for public safety. When you compare similar cities facing identical challenges—one encrypted, one open—the documented record says otherwise.
Two cities, two outcomes
These are real cities that faced real emergencies. Their outcomes differed based on one policy choice: whether the public could hear police communications.
Comparison 1: Highland Park vs Chicago
Highland Park, IL
Pop. 30,000After the 2022 parade shooting, Chicago newsrooms wrote that the media and the public turned to police scanners "to take cover, to stay safe, to locate the missing"
Chicago, IL
Pop. 2.7MChicago newsrooms wrote that a December 2022 courthouse shooting (more than 40 shots) was not reported as it happened because live transmissions were blocked
The Point: Same metro area, five months apart. Chicago newsrooms cited both in their December 2022 letter.
Comparison 2: Tampa vs Miami
Tampa, FL
Pop. 400,000Hosted Super Bowl 2021 with open radios; hurricane season coverage remains transparent
Miami, FL
Pop. 460,000Hurricane coverage now relies on delayed official sources; $25M system failed in 2014
The Point: Both face hurricanes, tourism, and crime. Only one chose transparency.
Highland Park: scanners during a mass shooting
On July 4, 2022, a gunman opened fire during Highland Park's Independence Day parade, killing seven people and wounding 48. In December 2022, Chicago's major newsrooms wrote that "as news unfolded about the July 4th shooting in Highland Park, the media and the public turned to police scanners and reporting informed by police scanners to take cover, to stay safe, to locate the missing" (coalition letter).
That is the newsrooms' account. We have not found a named resident's published account of using a scanner that day, a count of listeners, or a dated source on whether Highland Park police dispatch was encrypted in 2022. As of October 2026, RadioReference lists the East Shore law dispatch talkgroup for Highland Park, Highwood, Lake Bluff and Lake Forest police as fully encrypted.
Chicago: encrypted radios, no public warning
Twenty-five miles south, Chicago uses one of the most restrictive encryption policies in the country. When a gunman fired more than 40 shots outside a Chicago courthouse that same year, the public received no information for 30 minutes.
First shots fired at courthouse
Police dispatch (encrypted—public hears nothing)
Complete information blackout for 30 minutes
Delayed, censored audio finally becomes available
Official press release issued
What encryption blocked:
- No warning for people near the courthouse while shots were being fired
- No independent media verification of what happened
- No way for families to track conditions in the area
- No public information until the active danger had passed
- Police controlled the entire narrative from the start
Impact by group
Open versus encrypted communications lands differently depending on who you are. These tables show the practical differences for journalists, residents, and emergency responders.
Impact on journalists
| Category | Open City | Encrypted City |
|---|---|---|
| Breaking News | Immediate awareness of incidents; can dispatch crews within minutes | 30+ minute delay or reliance on official press releases |
| Source Verification | Independent verification of police claims in real-time | Must accept official narrative; no independent check |
| Public Safety Alerts | Can broadcast warnings about active threats immediately | Warnings delayed until official channels update |
| Accountability | Audio evidence of police communications during incidents | No record of initial communications available |
Chicago's 30-minute delay means audio reaches newsrooms only after the incident has concluded.
Impact on residents
| Category | Open City | Encrypted City |
|---|---|---|
| Active Threat Awareness | Know about shooters, pursuits, hazmat in real-time | Learn about dangers after the fact |
| Emergency Response Time | Can take protective action immediately | Wait for official alerts that may be delayed |
| Family Location | Track police activity to locate separated family during crises | No real-time information about incident areas |
| 911 Call Reduction | Scanner listeners do not need to call 911 for updates | Increased 911 volume from people seeking information |
Impact on emergency response
| Category | Open City | Encrypted City |
|---|---|---|
| Fire/EMS Coordination | Full situational awareness for volunteer and community responders | Interoperability issues; responders may not hear relevant transmissions from other agencies |
| Hurricane/Disaster Response | Real-time updates on conditions, evacuations, road closures | Reliance on delayed official channels during fast-moving events |
| Multi-Agency Events | Public can track coordination across agencies | Communication gaps between encrypted and open agencies |
| Community Watch | Neighborhood groups can monitor local activity | Community safety networks lose information access |
Tampa vs Miami: the Florida divide
Florida's internal divide makes the policy argument clearly. Tampa and Miami face the same challenges: hurricanes, tourism, drug trafficking, major events. Tampa stayed open; Miami went dark.
Tampa Bay Region
- Tampa PD: Open P25 digital
- Hillsborough County Sheriff: Open
- St. Petersburg PD: Mostly accessible
- Hosted Super Bowl 2021 with open radios
- Hurricane coverage fully transparent
Proves major metros can maintain open communications
South Florida Region
- Miami-Dade PD: Fully encrypted
- Miami Beach PD: Encrypted Dec 2021
- Broward County Sheriff: Encrypted
- $25M system failed in 2014; rebuilt at additional cost
- Hurricane coverage now delayed/filtered
Millions spent to block information from the public
Tampa hosted the Super Bowl in 2021, manages annual hurricane seasons, and handles all the same public safety demands Miami does—with open radios. Miami has never explained why its situation requires something Tampa chose not to do.
By the numbers
What this comparison shows
Encryption is a choice, not a necessity
Tampa faces the same challenges as Miami and chose differently. The comparison makes clear that encryption is about controlling information, not protecting officers.
Open access has documented benefits
After the Highland Park shooting, Chicago's major newsrooms put in writing that the media and the public turned to police scanners "to take cover, to stay safe, to locate the missing." We know of no comparable published account of encryption saving a life.
Encryption claims are unsupported
Police departments claim encryption protects officers and operations. When asked to produce incidents where scanner access caused harm, they cannot. Asked by a newspaper for three years of reports of scanner-aided crime, Palo Alto had none on record.
The public consistently loses
In every encrypted city, journalists lose independent verification, residents lose situational awareness, and responders lose coordination. The only party that gains is the department that now controls what the public knows.
How to use this evidence
If your city is considering encryption, these comparisons give you specific examples to bring to public meetings and officials:
Cite Highland Park
Quote the Chicago newsrooms' letter on how the public used scanners during the shooting, attributed to them. Ask officials to produce a counter-example where encryption saved a life.
Point to Tampa
Tampa manages the same demands as any major metro with open radios. If your city claims encryption is necessary, ask why Tampa reached a different conclusion.
Request records
File a FOIA request for incidents where scanner access harmed officers or operations. Palo Alto had none on record for three years. Most cities will find the same.
Show the cost
Miami spent $25M on a system that failed and had to be replaced. Chicago's 30-minute delay serves no public safety purpose. Ask officials to justify spending that blocks public information.
Take Action for Transparency
Your voice matters. Here are concrete ways to advocate for open police communications in your community.
Contact Your Representatives
Use our templates to email your local officials about police radio encryption policies.
Get startedRead Case Studies
See how encryption has affected real communities - from Chicago to Palo Alto.
View casesSpread Awareness
Share evidence about police radio encryption with your network and community.
Public Testimony
Learn how to speak effectively at city council and public safety meetings.
Prepare to speakSources and documentation
- Chicago news coalition open letter, NBC 5 Chicago, Dec. 12, 2022
- Chicago Police Department encryption policy documentation
- ABC7 Chicago reporting on scanner delays
- Tampa Police Department transparency portal
- Miami-Dade encryption implementation records
- Palo Alto Daily Post, May 28, 2021: city's "no responsive records" reply for 2018–2020
- NBC 6 South Florida: $25M Harris system failure (2014)