Advertisement
Landmark Victory

NYC Local Law 46: a city law mandating press access to police radio

On January 17, 2026, Local Law 46 was enacted in New York City, requiring the NYPD to make encrypted radio communications available to credentialed journalists. Weeks earlier, Governor Kathy Hochul had vetoed a statewide version of the same idea. The city acted anyway.

Key Facts at a Glance

41-7 City Council vote
Jan 17, 2026 Enacted into law
14 Press groups in the NY Media Consortium
Advertisement

What Local Law 46 requires

The law, introduced as Int. 1460-2025 by Manhattan City Council Member Gale Brewer, sets specific requirements for NYPD radio access:

Press access

Encrypted precinct, borough, transit, and housing bureau channels, and any other channel that does not routinely carry sensitive information, must be available to professional journalists holding city press credentials who pay reasonable costs. The statute sets no time limit on that access; the Council's bill summary described it as "in real time."

Public critical incident channel

The department must broadcast reports of critical incidents over an unencrypted, citywide channel accessible to the general public in real-time.

Policy development

NYPD has 180 days to publish a proposed policy on its website, followed by 45 days of public comment. The final policy must be posted, with an explanation of changes made in response to comments, no more than 45 days after the comment period ends.

Implementation timeline

The final policy must be implemented within 12 months of the law's effective date (it took effect immediately on enactment, January 17, 2026).

How it happened

Local Law 46 came out of years of advocacy after the NYPD's encryption rollout — begun in July 2023 as part of a roughly $390 million radio modernization — ended nearly a century of public scanner access.

July 2023

NYPD begins encrypting radio communications, starting with Brooklyn North precincts

2023–2024

14 media organizations rally under the New York Media Consortium to fight for access

November 12, 2025

City Council Member Gale Brewer introduces Int. 1460-2025

December 18, 2025

Public Safety Committee approves bill 9-0; full Council passes 41-7

December 19, 2025

Governor Hochul vetoes the statewide Keep Police Radio Public Act (S.416/A.3516)

January 17, 2026

Int. 1460 is enacted as Local Law 46 of 2026 without a mayoral signature

The media coalition

The New York Media Consortium united 14 press organizations behind a single ask. Collective pressure from a named coalition carried more weight than individual outlets lobbying separately.

Coalition members included:

  • New York News Guild and its locals
  • New York Press Photographers Association
  • Society of Professional Journalists (Deadline Club, NYC chapter)
  • Major news outlets and journalism organizations

A unified message—that press access serves the public, not just newsrooms—undercut the NYPD's attempt to frame the issue as a narrow professional dispute.

Why NYC succeeded where Albany failed

Hochul's December 19 veto landed a day after the Council passed Int. 1460 — and weeks before it became Local Law 46. The juxtaposition clarifies something useful about where these fights can be won.

State bill (vetoed)

  • Needed a single executive's signature
  • Faced statewide police union opposition
  • Less direct constituent pressure on the governor
  • Governor could decline without facing local consequences

NYC Local Law 46 (passed)

  • Became law without the mayor's signature
  • Council members answer directly to city constituents
  • The media coalition concentrated resources at the local level
  • New York's press corps has direct relationships with city officials

The takeaway: go local

When state government won't move, cities can act on their own. NYC did. Other cities whose state legislatures or governors are blocking transparency measures can take the same route.

NYPD's opposition—and why it failed

NYPD leadership raised the usual objections: officer safety, criminal exploitation of open radio. None of them held up.

NYPD claimed: "Bad guys use scanners"

For more than 90 years (1932-2023), NYPD radios were public, and we know of no named, documented case of scanner-related officer harm. The "bad guy with a scanner" scenario remained theoretical throughout that entire period.

NYPD claimed: "Full encryption is necessary"

The law doesn't require unencryption—it requires access for credentialed journalists. NYPD can maintain encryption while providing press access through other means.

NYPD claimed: "No good way to verify journalists"

The NYPD already issues press credentials. The infrastructure for verifying journalists exists and has worked for decades at crime scenes and press events.

Advertisement

What encryption was doing on the ground

The NYPD's 2023 encryption rollout caused documented problems before Local Law 46 addressed them:

EMS coordination failures

Volunteer EMS workers lost critical location information under encryption. EMT Josiah Williams described searching for officers at a stabbing scene because encryption blocked radio coordination between agencies.

Critical incident channel restores access

The law's unencrypted critical incident channel will ensure emergency responders and the public can receive real-time information about major events.

Journalism hampered without scanner access

Reporters couldn't independently verify police accounts of incidents, forcing reliance on official statements that sometimes proved inaccurate.

Independent verification restored for credentialed press

Credentialed journalists will again be able to verify police activity, arrive at scenes independently, and hold the department accountable.

What other cities can take from this

The elements that made Local Law 46 possible are replicable. None of them required New York-specific circumstances.

1

Build a coalition

The New York Media Consortium brought 14 organizations together. A named coalition is harder for officials to dismiss than individual outlets making the same ask separately.

2

Find champions inside government

Council Member Gale Brewer sponsored the bill; Speaker Adrienne Adams backed it. Identifying and cultivating those relationships early is not optional.

3

Work city hall, not the statehouse

State legislatures move slowly and face heavier police union lobbying. City council members are closer to their constituents and can act faster.

4

Write specific legislation

The bill named implementation timelines, public comment periods, and specific access requirements. Specificity closes off the objections that kill vague proposals.

5

Document the harms

The EMS coordination failures were concrete. Real incidents—not abstract arguments—are what persuade council members who are on the fence.

6

Keep going after a veto

The governor vetoed the statewide bill the day after the Council passed its own. The city had already found another path. A setback at one level doesn't end the fight.

What happens next

Local Law 46 sets specific compliance deadlines for the NYPD. Status as of October 12, 2026:

July 16, 2026

NYPD publishes its policy proposal. It says credentialed journalists' feeds "will be broadcast at a delay" without saying how long; the proposal originally set an August 30 comment deadline (as reproduced by amNY); the copy now posted says September 14.

Addendum

An NYPD addendum says journalists' access "will be provided on a one hour delay via a digital, internet-based platform," restates the proposal's limit to holders of Mayor's Office of Media and Entertainment press cards, proposes an acceptable-use policy barring publicly streaming or rebroadcasting the audio, and extends comments past August 30.

Sept 10, 2026

Council Member Gale Brewer introduces Int. 1025, which would require journalists' access "no more than 15 minutes after" a transmission and a system that lets users scan channels. It is referred to the Committee on Public Safety, where it remains as of October 2026.

Sept 13, 2026

Freedom of the Press Foundation files comments on the NYPD proposal and Int. 1025, saying New York City "is considering some of the most extreme anti-transparency proposals in the nation" and that it "should not limit listen-only access" to professional journalists.

Sept 14, 2026

Comment deadline listed on the NYPD's public-comment page (one copy of the addendum says September 13).

Next

The law requires the final policy within 45 days of the comment period's end, and implementation within 12 months of the law's effective date. As of October 12, 2026 the NYPD's comment page lists no response to comments and no final policy.

In its comment letter, the Freedom of the Press Foundation looked back to 9/11: "It's hard to fathom that the City might have implemented a 15 minute delay in access to life-or-death information which journalists work to share with evacuees..." The line is framed around 9/11, and the letter also addresses Int. 1025, which would cap the delay at 15 minutes. The letter does not say the NYPD proposed 15 minutes; the NYPD's addendum proposes one hour. Check the NYPD public-comment page for the current status.

Apply NYC's approach in your city

The text of Int. 1460-2025 can be adapted for other cities. The path NYC took was not unique to New York.

Study the law's language

Review Int. 1460-2025 and adapt its provisions to your city's legal framework. The access requirements, timelines, and comment periods are all replicable.

Build your coalition

Bring together local outlets, journalism schools, press clubs, and civil liberties groups. A unified ask beats a dozen uncoordinated ones.

Find your council champion

Gale Brewer sponsored the bill in NYC. Identify council members in your city who care about transparency and start building relationships before you need them.

Collect local examples

Document specific incidents where encryption blocked journalism or public safety coordination. Abstract arguments matter less than concrete cases.

Point to the NYC precedent

The argument that it can't be done in a major city no longer holds. Elected officials in other cities can be held to the same standard.

Act before the transition

Encryption is still spreading. The window to pass protective legislation is before a department goes fully dark, not after.

Sources

Build on this win

NYC proved it's possible. These resources will help you make the same case in your city.

Take Action for Transparency

Your voice matters. Here are concrete ways to advocate for open police communications in your community.

Contact Your Representatives

Use our templates to email your local officials about police radio encryption policies.

Get started

Read Case Studies

See how encryption has affected real communities - from Chicago to Palo Alto.

View cases

Spread Awareness

Share evidence about police radio encryption with your network and community.

See the Evidence

Review the facts, myths, and research on police radio encryption.

View evidence

Public Testimony

Learn how to speak effectively at city council and public safety meetings.

Prepare to speak

Download Resources

Get FOIA templates, talking points, and materials for advocacy.

Access toolkit

What you can do

Encryption is a policy choice, not a technical requirement. Here are the next steps that have worked in New York City and elsewhere.

Advertisement

Agency records in New York

Encryption status for individual agencies, each checked against a primary source where one was available.

All New York agencies →