The Victory That Changed Everything

On January 17, 2026, New York City's Local Law 46 was enacted, requiring the NYPD to make encrypted precinct, borough, transit and housing channels available to credentialed journalists, with sensitive information withheld. The City Council had passed Int. 1460-2025 by a vote of 41-7.

This wasn't luck. It was the result of strategic coalition-building, sustained pressure, and learning from failure. When Governor Hochul vetoed state legislation on December 19, 2025, advocates pivoted to local action and won.

This playbook documents exactly what worked so your city can replicate their success.

Campaign Timeline

Two Years from Crisis to Victory

July 2023

The blackout begins

NYPD encrypts six Brooklyn precincts (90th, 94th, 81st, 83rd, 84th, 88th), breaking a 92-year tradition of public radio access since 1932. For the first time, journalists cannot monitor police activity in Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Bushwick, and Bedford-Stuyvesant.

Todd Maisel of the NY Press Photographers Association begins organizing what would become the New York Media Consortium.
Fall 2023

Coalition forms

The New York Media Consortium officially launches with 8 founding organizations. Todd Maisel coordinated the effort, uniting competing newsrooms around a shared threat.

Frame the issue as affecting ALL media, not just one outlet. Competitors must become allies.
November 2023

State Senator Gianaris introduces bill

Queens Senator Michael Gianaris introduces S7759, the "Keep Police Radio Public Act." The bill would require statewide police access for credentialed journalists.

March 2024

City Council budget hearing

At a budget hearing on March 20, NYPD Chief of IT Ruben Beltran defends encryption citing "55 arrests in 2023 for unlawful possession of radio devices." When pressed for evidence of scanners harming officers, he provides only a single 2016 incident of radio threats.

Demand specific evidence. Vague claims collapse under scrutiny.
Summer 2024

Encryption expands citywide

All of Brooklyn, Staten Island, and the Bronx go dark. The coalition grows to 14 organizations as the threat becomes undeniable. The News Guild of New York and Communications Workers of America join.

June 2025

State Legislature passes bill

After two years of advocacy, both chambers of the NY State Legislature approve the Keep Police Radio Public Act (A.3516/S.416). Hopes rise for statewide solution.

November 12, 2025

Council Member Gale Brewer introduces Int. 1460-2025

With the state bill still awaiting the governor's decision, Brewer formally introduces the local backup legislation she had been developing.

December 18–19, 2025

Council committee and full Council pass Int. 1460-2025

The Public Safety Committee votes 9-0 to advance the bill; the full Council then passes it 41-7, a veto-proof supermajority.

December 19, 2025

Governor Hochul vetoes state bill

Governor Kathy Hochul vetoes the Keep Police Radio Public Act, citing public-safety concerns — including the risk of disclosing undercover officers' locations and movements. The coalition faces its darkest moment, on the same day the Council passed its own local version.

Rather than giving up, advocates lean on the local bill already moving through the Council. Council Member Gale Brewer had been developing that legislation as a backup plan.
January 17, 2026

Local Law 46 becomes law

Int. 1460-2025 takes effect as Local Law 46 of 2026 without Mayor Mamdani's signature; he formally returned the bill unsigned on January 20, 2026. NYPD has 180 days to publish implementation policy, 45 days of public comment, and 12 months from the law's effective date to implement the final policy.

The 14-Organization Coalition

How Competitors Became Allies

The New York Media Consortium proved that press freedom transcends competitive interests. These organizations normally compete for scoops, but encryption threatened them all equally.

Founding organizations (8)

  • New York Press Photographers Association - Led by Todd Maisel, the founding coordinator
  • NYS Broadcasters Association - Representing TV and radio stations
  • NYS Publishers Association - Representing newspapers statewide
  • NY Press Club - Historic journalism organization
  • Radio Television Digital News Association - National broadcast journalism group
  • American Society of Media Photographers - Visual journalism advocates
  • Society of Professional Journalists (Deadline Club) - NYC chapter
  • National Press Photographers Association - National advocacy backing

Expanded coalition (6 additional)

  • News Guild of New York - Union representing newsroom workers
  • Communications Workers of America - Parent union, national reach
  • NY News Guild Locals - Individual newsroom union chapters
  • News Media Alliance - National newspaper industry group
  • NYCLU - Civil liberties perspective
  • Legal Aid Society - Police accountability advocates

Why the coalition worked

Shared threat, united response

Encryption affected everyone equally. The New York Times and AM New York both lost access. This created genuine alignment despite competitive differences.

One spokesperson, many voices

Todd Maisel served as public coordinator, but each organization communicated through their own channels. This multiplied reach while maintaining message consistency.

Labor union credibility

Adding the News Guild and CWA transformed this from a "media industry" issue to a "workers' rights" issue. Politicians who might ignore editors listen to unions.

Civil liberties framing

The NYCLU and Legal Aid Society brought police accountability arguments that resonated with progressive council members. This wasn't just about journalism - it was about democratic oversight.

The Legislative Champion

Council Member Gale Brewer's Critical Role

Council Member Gale A. Brewer

Manhattan District 6 | Prime Sponsor, Int. 1460-2025

Gale Brewer brought decades of experience to the fight. As former Manhattan Borough President and a longtime transparency advocate, she understood both the legislative process and the public interest stakes.

Why Brewer was the right champion

  • Known for government transparency legislation
  • Respected across political factions
  • Strategic influence over bill advancement through committee position
  • Had been developing local backup legislation even as state efforts proceeded

Building the supermajority

Brewer built support across the political spectrum on the Council. The Public Safety Committee's 9-0 vote in December 2025 signaled broad momentum ahead of the 41-7 full Council vote.

Finding your champion

Look for council members who:

  • Have a track record on transparency or press freedom issues
  • Serve on relevant committees (public safety, government oversight)
  • Have relationships across political factions
  • Need a signature issue (new members often seek visibility)
  • Represent districts with strong media presence or journalism schools

The Arguments That Won

Messaging That Secured 41 Votes

Primary Frame

Press freedom, not just convenience

The coalition framed encryption as a constitutional issue, not an industry complaint. Susan DeCarava of the NY News Guild stated: "Journalists help keep New Yorkers safe." This positioned media access as a public service, not a privilege.

Historical Argument

92 years of tradition

The NYPD had operated with open radio since 1932. Advocates emphasized that encryption broke a century-old tradition with no named, documented case of officer harm that we know of. The burden of proof shifted to NYPD to justify the change.

Accountability Argument

Oversight enabled by scanners

The NYCLU documented how scanner access enabled independent coverage of the Amadou Diallo, Sean Bell, and Eric Garner killings. During the 2020 George Floyd protests, scanners were crucial for documenting police response. Encryption eliminates this oversight.

Public Safety Argument

Real-time information matters in emergencies

After the Highland Park parade shooting (July 4, 2022), Chicago's major newsrooms wrote that "the media and the public turned to police scanners and reporting informed by police scanners to take cover, to stay safe, to locate the missing" (coalition letter, Dec. 2022).

Cost Argument

$390 million for secrecy

The NYPD's P25 encryption system cost $390 million with no documented return on investment. We know of no named, documented case of scanners harming an officer. Advocates questioned why taxpayers funded unproven technology.

Evidence Challenge

Demanding proof

When NYPD cited "bad guys" using scanners, advocates demanded specific cases. Chief Beltran could only cite one 2016 incident of radio threats - not scanner-enabled crime. The evidence simply didn't exist.

Overcoming NYPD Opposition

Countering Every Argument

NYPD Claim
Coalition Response

"Bad guys are listening"

Mayor Adams: "Bad guys are listening to these channels. They know when we're responding."

Demanded evidence

When pressed, NYPD offered only a single 2016 incident of someone making threats over police radio - not evidence of criminals using scanners to evade officers. After 92 years of open radio, we know of no named, documented case.

"Officer safety requires encryption"

Chief Beltran cited "55 arrests for unlawful radio possession" in 2023.

Possession isn't harm

Possessing a scanner isn't the same as using it to harm officers. The coalition demanded evidence of actual harm. None was provided. This was security theater, not evidence-based policy.

Delayed access

amNY reported in 2026 that, three years earlier, an NYPD press-office commander said he expected to give the press encrypted radio at 15-30 minute delays.

Delays are censorship

A delay of that length eliminates real-time accountability during active incidents. By the time journalists learn about police action, events are over and evidence can be sanitized. The coalition demanded real-time access.

"Citywide 1 channel remains open"

NYPD claimed critical incidents would still be broadcast on unencrypted Citywide 1.

Incomplete and delayed

Advocates documented that many incidents went unreported on Citywide 1, were announced late, or omitted crucial details. NYPD controlled what was "critical," enabling selective transparency.

Implementation feasibility concerns

Part of Governor Hochul's veto rationale for the state bill.

Other cities do it

Multiple jurisdictions provide media access to encrypted radio through special equipment. The coalition pivoted to local legislation where the City Council could mandate NYPD compliance regardless of technical excuses.

The Compromise That Worked

Media Access vs. Full Public Access

What the coalition won

✓
Access for credentialed journalists

Encrypted precinct, borough, transit, and housing bureau channels must be available to professional journalists. The statute sets no time limit; the Council's bill summary described the access as "in real time," and the NYPD has proposed a one-hour delay (see the status update below).

✓
Unencrypted critical incident broadcasts

NYPD must broadcast critical incidents on an unencrypted citywide channel accessible to the general public in real-time.

✓
Implementation timeline with public input

180 days to publish a proposed policy, 45 days of public comment, a final policy within 45 days after comment closes, and 12 months to implement. The police commissioner must consider comments and explain any changes made in response.

✓
Reasonable cost cap

Media organizations pay "reasonable costs, not to exceed" NYPD's actual expenses. Prevents cost as a barrier to access.

What was traded away

✗
Full public access to encrypted channels

The general public does not receive access to encrypted precinct-level communications, even with a delay. Only credentialed media.

✗
Time-delayed public access

Original drafts included delayed public access. This was removed in final negotiations. Some advocates view this as a significant concession.

Was this compromise worth it?

Yes, for strategic reasons: getting credentialed journalists back in the loop restores the primary accountability mechanism. Journalists can report on police activity, even if individual citizens can't monitor directly.

But it's not ideal. Public access remains restricted. Future advocacy should push for civilian access with reasonable delays. Local Law 46 is a floor, not a ceiling.

The precedent matters: NYC proved that police departments can be required to provide access. This framework can be improved in other cities or in future NYC amendments.

Implementation Details

How the Law Actually Works

1

Policy development (180 days)

NYPD must publish a proposal of the written policy on its website within 180 days of the law's effective date. It published its proposal on July 16, 2026.

2

Public comment (45 days)

The public had 45 days to submit comments to the police commissioner (the NYPD took them at radioaccess@nypd.org; the deadline, extended, was September 14, 2026). Comments could:

  • Challenge overly restrictive credential requirements
  • Demand inclusion of specific channels
  • Object to broad "sensitive information" exceptions
  • Propose technical improvements
3

Full implementation (1 year)

The law requires the NYPD to implement its final policy within 12 months of the law's effective date, including:

  • Journalist access to encrypted precinct, borough, transit and housing channels (the statute sets no time limit; as of October 2026 the NYPD proposes an internet platform on a one-hour delay)
  • Unencrypted citywide channel for reports of critical incidents
  • Access limited to journalists with city press credentials who pay reasonable costs

Enforcement mechanism

The law empowers the City Council to conduct oversight hearings and demand compliance reports. Media organizations can also pursue legal action for non-compliance. The coalition continues monitoring implementation.

Update: implementation status as of October 2026

The NYPD published its proposed policy on July 16, 2026. It said journalists' feeds "will be broadcast at a delay" without giving a length. A later NYPD addendum says access "will be provided on a one hour delay via a digital, internet-based platform," and extends public comment past the original August 30 deadline. Both documents limit access to holders of Mayor's Office of Media and Entertainment press cards. The NYPD's public-comment page lists September 14, 2026.

On September 10, 2026, Council Member Gale Brewer introduced Int. 1025, which would require journalists' access "no more than 15 minutes after" a transmission. It has been referred to the Committee on Public Safety, where it remains as of October 2026. On September 13, the Freedom of the Press Foundation filed comments on both, saying New York City "is considering some of the most extreme anti-transparency proposals in the nation." As of October 12, 2026, the NYPD's comment page lists no response to comments and no final policy.

Sources: NYPD policy proposal (PDF) · NYPD addendum (PDF) · NYPD public-comment page · Int. 1025 (Legistar) · Freedom of the Press Foundation comment letter (PDF)

Lessons for Other Cities

What You Can Replicate

1

Build your coalition before the crisis

Don't wait until encryption is announced. Identify press freedom groups, unions, civil liberties organizations, and sympathetic officials now. Relationships built before crisis are stronger than those forged under pressure.

2

Have backup plans at multiple levels

NYC pursued state and local legislation simultaneously. When Governor Hochul vetoed the state bill, the local option was ready. Always have alternatives: city council, county board, ballot initiative.

3

Demand evidence, not claims

Police will cite "officer safety" and "bad guys." Demand specific cases. Request FOIA documents. When NYC advocates pressed, NYPD could only produce one vague 2016 incident. The evidence doesn't exist because the threat isn't real.

4

Frame it as constitutional, not convenient

This isn't about journalists' convenience - it's about First Amendment press freedom and democratic accountability. Position your coalition as defending constitutional rights, not industry interests.

5

Build supermajority support

NYC's 41-7 vote was veto-proof. If your mayor might veto transparency legislation, ensure council support strong enough to override. This requires working both sides of the aisle.

6

Include implementation details in the law

Vague mandates get ignored. NYC's law specifies timelines, public comment periods, and specific access requirements. Don't let police departments claim "we're working on it" indefinitely.

7

Accept strategic compromises

NYC traded full public access for credentialed journalist access. This wasn't ideal, but it restored the primary accountability mechanism. Perfect shouldn't be the enemy of good. You can expand rights later.

8

Persist through setbacks

Governor Hochul's veto could have ended the fight. Instead, advocates pivoted to local action within weeks and won. Setbacks are redirections, not endings.

Template Materials

Adapt for Your City

The following templates are based on NYC's successful campaign. Modify for your jurisdiction, local officials, and specific circumstances.

Coalition formation letter

Subject: Invitation to Join [City] Media Access Coalition

Dear [Organization Leader],

Police radio encryption threatens independent journalism in [City]. When police control what the public knows about police activity, accountability dies.

We are forming a coalition of media organizations, civil liberties groups, and transparency advocates to fight for continued public access. New York City's recent victory (Local Law 46) proves this fight is winnable.

Will [Organization] join us? A unified voice of [X] organizations is harder to ignore than individual complaints.

Next steps: [Meeting date/time/location]

Council member request

Subject: Request for Meeting: Police Radio Transparency Legislation

Dear Council Member [Name],

We represent [X organizations] concerned about police radio encryption in [City]. We request a meeting to discuss legislation modeled on New York City's Local Law 46, which passed 41-7 and requires police to make encrypted radio channels available to credentialed journalists.

[City] faces similar challenges. [Cite local encryption status or plans.] We believe transparency and public safety are compatible, and we have model legislation ready for your consideration.

Available times: [List 3-4 options]

Public comment template

My name is [Name] and I am a [resident/journalist/organization representative] in [City].

I urge the Council to pass legislation requiring police to maintain transparency in radio communications. New York City's Local Law 46 provides a proven model.

Key points:

  • No named, documented case of police scanner access harming officers that we know of
  • Real-time information matters in emergencies (Chicago newsrooms on the Highland Park shooting)
  • Encryption eliminates independent oversight of police activity
  • NYC proved this is legally and technically feasible

Thank you.

Op-ed framework

Headline: [City] Needs NYC's Police Transparency Law

Opening: [Local hook - recent incident, encryption news, or accountability failure]

Problem: Police encryption eliminates independent oversight. [Local examples of impact]

Solution: NYC's Local Law 46 requires press access to encrypted radio. [City] should follow.

Evidence: No named, documented case of a scanner-harmed officer that we know of. Chicago's newsrooms wrote that during the Highland Park shooting the public turned to scanners "to take cover, to stay safe, to locate the missing."

Call to Action: Contact [specific officials] and demand transparency legislation.

Closing: Democracy requires informed citizens. [City] deserves better than police-controlled information.

Additional Resources: For model legislation language, FOIA request templates, and evidence packages, see:

Take Action for Transparency

Your voice matters. Here are concrete ways to advocate for open police communications in your community.

Contact Your Representatives

Use our templates to email your local officials about police radio encryption policies.

Get started

Read Case Studies

See how encryption has affected real communities - from Chicago to Palo Alto.

View cases

Spread Awareness

Share evidence about police radio encryption with your network and community.

See the Evidence

Review the facts, myths, and research on police radio encryption.

View evidence

Public Testimony

Learn how to speak effectively at city council and public safety meetings.

Prepare to speak

Download Resources

Get FOIA templates, talking points, and materials for advocacy.

Access toolkit