RTL-SDR V4 vs Airspy HF+ Discovery: $35 or $169?
These two SDRs target completely different users. The RTL-SDR V4 is a general-purpose workhorse covering everything from HF to UHF at $35. The Airspy HF+ Discovery is a specialist HF/VHF receiver that doesn't cover UHF at all — but what it does, it does with 16-bit precision the V4 can't match. Here's how to decide.
Quick Answer: Which Should You Buy?
Choose RTL-SDR V4 If:
- You want to monitor police, fire, or EMS radio
- You need UHF coverage (any frequency above 260 MHz)
- You're a beginner starting with SDR
- Budget is a consideration
- You want broadband scanning capability
- You'll use it for ADS-B, NOAA, or trunked radio
Choose Airspy HF+ If:
- You're serious about shortwave or medium wave DX
- You chase weak signals below 30 MHz
- You already own an RTL-SDR and want an HF upgrade
- You monitor amateur HF bands (20m, 40m, 80m)
- Band congestion and interference affect your reception
Feature Comparison
| Feature | RTL-SDR Blog V4 | Airspy HF+ Discovery |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $35-45 | $169-219 |
| ADC Resolution | 8-bit effective | 16-bit effective |
| Frequency Coverage | 500 kHz – 1766 MHz | 500 kHz – 31 MHz + 60–260 MHz |
| UHF Coverage | Yes (up to 1766 MHz) | No (tops out at 260 MHz) |
| P25 Police Scanning | Yes | No (UHF not covered) |
| HF Dynamic Range | Good | Excellent (pre-selection filters) |
| Bias-T | Yes (4.5V) | No |
| SDR# Compatible | Yes | Yes (with plugin) |
| Instantaneous Bandwidth | 2.4 MHz (usable) | 660 kHz (higher quality) |
| Best Use | Broadband scanning, beginners | HF/MW DX, serious shortwave |
What the 16-Bit ADC Actually Means
HF Sensitivity and Dynamic Range
The Airspy HF+ Discovery's 16-bit ADC (versus the RTL-SDR V4's 8-bit) produces dramatically lower noise and dramatically better dynamic range on HF. Dynamic range determines whether strong signals from nearby stations "bleed over" and mask weaker distant stations. On a crowded 40-meter amateur band or a busy MW broadcast band, the difference is audible. The RTL-SDR V4 handles it reasonably well but can exhibit more intermodulation products in the presence of many strong nearby signals.
Why the Airspy HF+ Skips UHF
The HF+ is purpose-built for HF and low VHF performance. Designing a single receiver that's excellent from 500 kHz to 1766 MHz would require compromises. Airspy made the deliberate choice to optimize for HF at the expense of UHF coverage. This is the right trade-off if your priority is shortwave DX — but it means the HF+ literally cannot receive your local P25 police frequencies.
Pre-Selection Filters
The Airspy HF+ includes automatic pre-selection bandpass filters that engage based on the frequency you're tuning. These filters reject strong out-of-band signals before they reach the ADC — particularly important near broadcast AM stations that can swamp less filtered receivers. The RTL-SDR V4 has no such filtering (though you can add external LNAs with filters).
Best Receiver by Use Case
Police / Fire / EMS Scanning
Winner: RTL-SDR V4
Public safety operates at VHF/UHF. Airspy HF+ doesn't cover these frequencies at all.
Shortwave DX
Winner: Airspy HF+
16-bit ADC and pre-selection filters make a real difference chasing weak signals below 30 MHz.
Medium Wave / AM Broadcast
Winner: Airspy HF+
Near-broadcast-tower dynamic range makes the HF+ the clear winner in the MW band.
ADS-B Aircraft
Winner: RTL-SDR V4
ADS-B operates at 1090 MHz, well above the Airspy HF+'s 260 MHz ceiling.
Amateur HF (20m, 40m, 80m)
Winner: Airspy HF+
HF amateur bands fall squarely in the HF+'s optimized range. Better reception on a crowded 20m.
First SDR
Winner: RTL-SDR V4
Broader coverage, more learning opportunities, and a much lower risk of regretting a $169 purchase.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Airspy HF+ worth 5x the price of RTL-SDR V4?
For HF shortwave, MW broadcast, and serious DX listening — yes. The Airspy HF+ Discovery uses a 16-bit effective ADC versus the RTL-SDR V4's 8-bit, resulting in dramatically better dynamic range and sensitivity on HF frequencies. If you primarily monitor police/fire/EMS VHF, no — RTL-SDR V4 is more than sufficient and the extra $130 adds nothing useful.
Which covers more frequencies?
RTL-SDR V4 has broader coverage: roughly 500 kHz to 1766 MHz. The Airspy HF+ Discovery only covers 500 kHz–31 MHz and 60–260 MHz — it intentionally skips the UHF range above 260 MHz. The HF+ is built for HF excellence, not broadband coverage.
Can RTL-SDR V4 replace an Airspy HF+ for shortwave?
For casual shortwave listening and broadcast station reception, yes. For serious DX chasing (weak signal reception from distant stations), medium wave, or low-frequency amateur band work, no. The Airspy HF+'s 16-bit ADC and dedicated pre-selection filters make a noticeable difference when signals are weak or band conditions are crowded.
Which is better for P25 police scanner use?
RTL-SDR V4, unambiguously. P25 and other public safety digital modes operate at VHF and UHF (137–900 MHz). The Airspy HF+ doesn't cover this range — it tops out at 260 MHz on VHF and has no UHF coverage at all. RTL-SDR V4 + SDRTrunk is the standard P25 SDR setup.
Do they use the same software?
Partially. Both work with SDR# (SDRSharp). The Airspy HF+ requires its own driver plugin that installs alongside the Airspy driver. RTL-SDR V4 uses the standard RTL-SDR drivers. GQRX, SDRangel, and SDRUno also support both, but setup steps differ. RTL-SDR V4 has broader software ecosystem support.
Take Action for Transparency
Your voice matters. Here are concrete ways to advocate for open police communications in your community.
Contact Your Representatives
Use our templates to email your local officials about police radio encryption policies.
Get StartedRead Case Studies
See how encryption has affected real communities - from Highland Park to Chicago.
View CasesSpread Awareness
Share evidence about police radio encryption with your network and community.
Public Testimony
Learn how to speak effectively at city council and public safety meetings.
Prepare to Speak