Print this card and bring it to meetings. It fits in a pocket and covers the main points and counter-arguments.
Talking Points
Police Radio Encryption 1
No named, documented case supports the "officer safety" claim
No named, documented case of scanner-related officer harm that we know of; a 2022 CISA paper cites only anonymized examples.
2
Encryption costs millions with no proven benefit
NYPD: $390M. Philadelphia: $80M. No ROI for public safety.
3
Alternatives address the real concerns
Tactical-only encryption, delayed feeds, and hybrid models protect sensitive operations without going dark entirely.
4
Fire and EMS leaders have testified against it
Encryption creates interoperability gaps that slow multi-agency emergency responses.
5
Chicago's newsrooms on Highland Park
After the 2022 parade shooting, they wrote that the media and the public turned to police scanners "to take cover, to stay safe, to locate the missing."
Counter-Arguments
Responding to Claims"Officers' safety is at risk"
→ Ask for documented incidents. There are none. The risk is theoretical.
"Criminals use scanners to evade police"
→ Modern criminals use cell phones and encrypted apps. The scanner argument is decades out of date.
"We provide press releases instead"
→ Press releases are written after the fact and only say what the department chooses to share.
"Media can apply for access"
→ Credential programs shut out freelancers and new outlets, and typically still don't provide real-time access.
"Other cities have done it"
→ Some have. Others reversed it after community pressure — including Palo Alto and Boulder.
How to use this card
- Print on cardstock if possible for durability
- Cut along the dotted lines
- Fold in half or keep both sides visible
- Bring to city council meetings and public comment sessions
- Review key points before speaking
- Reference counter-arguments when responding to officials