Advertisement
St. Paul, Minnesota

St. Paul Police Encryption: Following Minneapolis

Following Minneapolis, St. Paul police planned to start encrypting in October 2025 and finish by January 2026. Real-time access to police radio is shrinking across a metro of 3.79 million residents.

Key facts

calendar
Planned Start October 2025
people
Population ~307,000 (Vintage 2025 est.)
region
Metro Population 3.79 Million (Vintage 2025 est.)

Twin Cities Regional Encryption

When Minneapolis encrypted in spring 2025, St. Paul's move was predictable. The two cities share a border and coordinate on major incidents. St. Paul's plan became public in late April 2025, as Minneapolis prepared to go fully encrypted on May 1 (Pioneer Press).

Encryption now covers Minneapolis police, the Hennepin County Sheriff (since 2019), Edina and St. Louis Park police, and the Carver, Dakota and Scott county sheriffs (Star Tribune). The metro area's 3.79 million residents (Census Bureau Vintage 2025 estimate) have shrinking real-time access to police communications.

Regional pressure, regional result

Minneapolis's encryption put St. Paul in an awkward position. The argument was straightforward: if Minneapolis is dark, anyone wanting to monitor police can just look across the river. This "last holdout" dynamic has driven regional domino effects elsewhere, including in the East Bay in California.

Advertisement

The protest rationale

St. Paul's leadership pointed to 2020 explicitly. Assistant Chief Paul Ford told the Star Tribune that the department needs to encrypt to comply with federal rules for radio traffic and to protect witness and victim information, and said rioters used scanner information following Floyd's murder: "A lot of the violent protesters, they were listening to our radios, and they were operating and changing their tactics based on what we were doing" (Star Tribune, Sept. 3, 2025). Minneapolis gave different reasons for its own switch: officer safety and the privacy of crime victims (MPR News).

Unpacking this claim

  • Listening to public radio broadcasts and sharing information is protected First Amendment activity—protesters exercising free speech were doing nothing wrong
  • No public evidence ties scanner monitoring by protesters here to officer injuries or compromised operations
  • The same logic would justify encrypting any public information that protesters might use
  • If scanner monitoring during protests was a genuine concern, why did St. Paul wait until 2025 to plan it?

Using protests against police violence as justification for reducing police transparency creates a direct problem: it frames public accountability as the threat rather than police conduct.

Minnesota's statewide trend

St. Paul's encryption is part of a statewide pattern. Minnesota's ARMER (Allied Radio Matrix for Emergency Response) system lets agencies encrypt without major infrastructure changes. Flipping the switch is easy.

2019 Hennepin County Sheriff encrypts—first in Minnesota
2023–2025 Others follow, including Dakota County (Sept 2023), Edina, St. Louis Park, and Carver and Scott counties
May 2025 Minneapolis Police encrypts (testing from April 14; encrypted in May 2025, per the Star Tribune)
Fall 2025 St. Paul Police plans to start encrypting (October)
2028 Anoka County plans to encrypt, per the Star Tribune
Advertisement

Impact on Twin Cities journalism

The Twin Cities have a substantial local journalism ecosystem: the Star Tribune, Pioneer Press, MPR News, MinnPost, and a range of community outlets. All of them used scanner access for breaking news.

Breaking news

Journalists can no longer respond to incidents as they develop. By the time official information is released, the story has often moved on.

Independent verification

Scanner traffic provided a check on official police statements. Without it, journalists must rely more heavily on police communications offices.

Pattern detection

Monitoring scanner traffic allowed journalists to identify patterns in police response that might not be apparent from individual incident reports.

Stakeholder perspectives

Encryption hits different parts of the community differently:

Lynne Crockett, north Minneapolis resident

"It's been a bit frustrating... Now I just hear a lot of sirens."

Situational awareness has dropped for residents who relied on scanner traffic to know what was happening nearby.

Sheriff Bob Fletcher, Ramsey County

Losing scanner access is "a big loss."

Even law enforcement leadership has acknowledged what the public gives up when scanner access ends.

Rick Abbott, founder, MN Crime Watch

Abbott's MN Crime Watch relied on scanner monitoring to relay incident information to the public; encryption removes that source for community crime-alert coverage.

Catherine Cowley, volunteer scanner poster

Cowley volunteered to relay scanner traffic online for community awareness—a role that encryption eliminates.

Quotes and details via the Star Tribune: "St. Paul is latest to lock down police radio traffic as Minneapolis encryption sparks debate".

George Floyd's legacy: a troubling justification

St. Paul's use of the 2020 protests as partial justification for encryption raises a direct question about what accountability is supposed to look like in a region still processing the George Floyd killing.

The protest context

Following George Floyd's murder by Minneapolis police, protests erupted across the Twin Cities. St. Paul's assistant chief says protesters listened to police radios. Federal wiretap law expressly permits listening to police and fire radio that is readily accessible to the general public (18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(g)(ii)).

The troubling logic

Using protests against police violence as justification for reducing police transparency creates a concerning precedent. It suggests that public accountability itself is the problem—that citizens knowing what police are doing is inherently dangerous.

No named case of harm

Despite the protest rationale, no evidence has been presented showing that scanner monitoring during 2020 led to officer injuries or compromised operations. The justification relies on hypothetical concerns, not documented harm.

Five years later

If scanner monitoring during protests was such an urgent concern, why did St. Paul wait until 2025 to plan it? The timing suggests the protest rationale may be post-hoc justification rather than genuine operational necessity.

What you can do

St. Paul residents

  • Contact the St. Paul City Council about transparency concerns
  • Attend city council meetings and raise encryption during public comment
  • Support local journalism that covers police accountability
  • File data practices requests for specific incidents
St. Paul City Council: Meets Wednesdays at 3:30 PM at City Hall, 15 Kellogg Blvd W. Public comment available during meetings.

Minnesota statewide

  • Advocate for state legislation requiring press access policies
  • Follow Colorado's HB21-1250 as a model
  • Contact your state legislators about encryption concerns
  • Build coalitions with journalism and civil liberties groups
Find your legislator: Visit leg.mn.gov to find your state representative and senator. District 64-67 cover St. Paul.

Support local media

  • Subscribe to local news outlets covering police accountability
  • Share stories about encryption's impact on public safety
  • Write letters to the editor supporting transparency
  • Contact MPR, Star Tribune, and Pioneer Press about coverage
Key outlets: Star Tribune, Pioneer Press, MPR News, MinnPost, Sahan Journal, and community newspapers.

Document impacts

  • Keep records of incidents where encryption affected your awareness
  • Note when you learned about nearby emergencies late
  • Track rumors that spread in the absence of scanner information
  • Share specific examples with elected officials
Why it matters: Specific documented examples are more persuasive than abstract concerns when advocating for transparency.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did St. Paul police encrypt their radios?

St. Paul police said in April 2025 that they would start encrypting in October 2025 and finish programming radios in January 2026 (Pioneer Press), following Minneapolis, which encrypted in spring 2025. As of Oct 13, 2026 RadioReference lists both clear and encrypted versions of St. Paul's district dispatch talkgroups, but only the encrypted ones show recent Broadcastify Calls activity, so St. Paul dispatch appears to be encrypted.

Why did St. Paul encrypt police radio?

Assistant Chief Paul Ford told the Star Tribune (September 2025) that the department needs to encrypt to comply with federal rules for radio traffic and to protect witness and victim information. Ford also said that after George Floyd's murder, "violent protesters" listened to St. Paul police radios and changed their tactics. Ramsey County Sheriff Bob Fletcher, an encryption opponent, told the Star Tribune he hasn't seen evidence to support the argument that suspects might be listening to the scanner.

Can I still listen to St. Paul police scanners?

Probably not for dispatch. St. Paul planned to finish encrypting by January 2026, and as of Oct 13, 2026 RadioReference lists both clear and encrypted versions of St. Paul's district dispatch talkgroups, but only the encrypted ones show recent Broadcastify Calls activity. Check RadioReference for the live answer. Minneapolis, by contrast, offers a 911 calls dashboard delayed by 30 minutes.

Is all of the Twin Cities area encrypted now?

Not all of it. Minneapolis police, the Hennepin County Sheriff (since 2019), Edina and St. Louis Park police, and the Carver, Dakota and Scott county sheriffs have encrypted (Star Tribune, September 2025). Ramsey County said it planned to encrypt only its data channels, not its main channels, and RadioReference lists Ramsey County law dispatch in the clear as of October 2026.

What alternatives to full encryption could St. Paul implement?

St. Paul could implement several transparency-preserving alternatives: time-delayed public feeds (like Minneapolis's 30-minute dashboard), tactical-only encryption (encrypting sensitive operations while keeping routine calls open), media credential programs for real-time access, or a public information channel for major incidents.

How can I advocate for transparency in St. Paul?

Contact St. Paul City Council members about transparency concerns, attend public meetings, support local journalism, file data practices requests for incident information, and advocate for state legislation requiring press access policies. Building coalitions with journalism organizations and civil liberties groups amplifies your voice.

Sources

What you can do

Encryption is a policy choice, not a technical requirement. Here are the next steps that have worked in St. Paul and elsewhere.

Take Action for Transparency

Your voice matters. Here are concrete ways to advocate for open police communications in your community.

Contact Your Representatives

Use our templates to email your local officials about police radio encryption policies.

Get started

Read Case Studies

See how encryption has affected real communities - from Chicago to Palo Alto.

View cases

Spread Awareness

Share evidence about police radio encryption with your network and community.

See the Evidence

Review the facts, myths, and research on police radio encryption.

View evidence

Public Testimony

Learn how to speak effectively at city council and public safety meetings.

Prepare to speak

Download Resources

Get FOIA templates, talking points, and materials for advocacy.

Access toolkit
Advertisement

Agency records in Minnesota

Encryption status for individual agencies, each checked against a primary source where one was available.

All Minnesota agencies →